Error rendering component

Violent conflicts, cease fires and peace accords through the lens of Indigenous Peoples

Annual Forum conference, October 21st-23rd 2009 


The 2009 Forum Conference addresses situations of violent conflicts, unstable ceasefires, and both fragile and successful peace accords affecting indigenous peoples in Asia, Africa and Latin America. The carefully selected cases highlight conflicts, transition stages of “no-peace no-war,” or post-conflict situations. Often, assertion of indigenous rights through organised resistance and struggle against state institutions fuelled the conflicts, and recognition of rights-based demands tends to be crucial for ending conflicts and ensuring sustained peace. The reasons why some of the conflicts have escalated into fractious conflicts between ethnic groups or clans will also be addressed. All the highlighted situations address serious rights violations that have occurred during the protracted conflicts and ceasefires – many of which are ongoing. We seek to answer the question of why these grave discriminations and other violations often remain largely invisible in the national and international media and under-reported by responsible human rights organizations.

The three sub-themes described below will be addressed mainly through the lens of indigenous perceptions of justice and rights. Invited speakers include prominent indigenous leaders representing indigenous and ethnic or inter-ethnic umbrella organisations (both intermediary and national) that play crucial roles in the process of negotiating to end the conflict and building peace.

Sub-themes:

1. Unknown sufferings: perpetrators and victims of violence and its invisibility
This session addresses the on-the-ground realities of violence affecting indigenous women, children and men during conflicts and after the guns have been silenced. During so-called “ethnic conflicts,” the roles of perpetrator or victim are often manipulated by interested actors. This is currently the case in a number of conflict-ridden areas in Africa, Asia and Latin America where indigenous peoples live.

This session highlights perpetrator-victim dynamics, the nature of violence (including murder, torture, sexualised violence and eviction) and both its obvious and less-visible consequences. It will also examine institutional and political reasons behind media bias, including the lack of attention violence against indigenous peoples, and will address the inconsistent human rights reporting of such crimes to the relevant international bodies (including the International Criminal Court and the UN bodies).

2. Examining the preconditions for building sustainable peace
In a number of cases, protracted violent conflict between militant indigenous movements struggling for greater autonomy and state security forces have eventually led to peace accords. These accords often remain contested by splinter militia, guerrilla groups and certain state actors; this session addresses major stumbling blocs confronting some of such peace-building processes. The preconditions for successful disarmament, demobilization, and reintegration, or DDR, will be an important point of discussion. This session invites political-economic analysis, and asks why state security forces, their political allies and some break-off guerrilla groups are sometimes ambivalent to or actively oppose implementation of the peace accords.

3. Norway’s bilateral and multilateral challenges in contributing in peace building and monitoring of peace accords
Norway has an international reputation as peace facilitator and mediator. Yet Norway has not often taken a leading role in negotiating ceasefires and peace accords between state parties and militant indigenous organizations, or in implementing effective monitoring mechanisms for signed ceasefires and treaties Given: Norway’s duties as a state party to the International Rights regime; its policy on Human Rights and Indigenous Rights; and its credibility as a bilateral and multilateral development partner, how can Norway play a more effective role in conflict hotspots?

The last part of this session will, after short introductions, be organised as a Roundtable Discussion on the effectiveness of Norway’s policies with representation from IWGIA, Galdu, The Centre for Peace Studies (CPS) at the University of Tromsø and from the present representatives of national indigenous organizations.

The Forum for Development Cooperation with Indigenous Peoples is a meeting place for researchers, development workers and Sámi organisations engaged in cooperation with indigenous peoples in the South. By initiating important debates concerning policies and practice, the Forum seeks to improve the quality of Norway’s development co-operation with indigenous peoples elsewhere. The Forum has a Board located with the Centre for Sámi Studies at the University of Tromsø, with external representation from other research institutions, Indigenous advocacy NGOs and the Sámi Council.

The conference languages will be English, Spanish and Sami. 

Programme

21st October

20:00 Reception at Árdna, the Sámi cultural building located at the University campus, close to “Labyrinten”, The Sámi turf hut and the Administration building.
21:30 Bus departure from the University to Radisson SAS hotel

 

22nd October

Opening of conference
08:30 Taxi departure from Rica Ishavshotel hotel to the University
08:45 - 09:15 Registration, at University Campus, Teorifagbygget, Hus 1, Auditorium 1.
09:15 - 09:25: Opening by Deputy Chair Marit Myrvoll, Centre for Sami studies, University of Tromsø
09:25 - 09:45: Opening by Tone Bleie, Chair, Forum for Development Cooperation with Indigenous Peoples: Violent conflicts, ceasefires and peace accords through the lens of indigenous peoples
Subtheme 1:
Unknown sufferings: perpetrators and victims of violence and its invisibility
09:45 - 10:15 Tonol Murmu, a Santal and the Executive Secretary of AISWACS (All India Santal Welfare and Cultural Society), or Bhanu Rabha, Indigenous leader of AISWACS: “Bodo-Santal conflicts in Assam: The evil designs, silent sufferings and the process of reconciliation
10:15 - 10:45  Discussion
10:45 - 11:15 Coffee
11:15 - 11:45  Jennifer Hays, Research Fellow in Comparative Indigenous Studies, University of Tromsø: The Invasion of Nyae Nyae: A case study in on-going aggression against indigenous hunter-gatherers in Namibia
11:45 - 12:15 Robert Hitchcock, Professor from the University of Michigan: Genocide and Indigenous People or The reasons for the escalation of violent conflicts between hunter/gatherers and pastoralists in Southern and Eastern Africa
12:15 - 12:45 Discussion
12:45 - 13:45 Lunch
13:45 - 14:15 Juan Leon, Ambassador of Guatemala in Norway: Guatemala: The situation of the Maya peoples after the Civil War and Peace agreements
14:15 - 14:30 Discussion
Subtheme 2:
Examining the preconditions for building sustainable peace
14:30 - 15:00 Adolphine Byayuwa Muley, Bukavu, South-Kivu: The killings and lack of attention to Twa/Pygmy groups in both the current fighting (DRC governmental forces – mainly against Hutu militias) and the DDR efforts in the region
15:00 - 15:15 Coffee
15:15 - 15:45  Saoudata Aboubacrine, Tin Hinan (Mali): Les accords de paix entre les mouvements Touarègue et le Mali/The peace accords between the Tuareg movements, and the government of Mali
15:45 - 16:15 Sanjeeb Drong, Bangladesh Adivasi Forum: Indigenous Peoples of Bangladesh: Invisible war in the Garo Hills and and North-West Bangladesh and non-implementation of the CHT Peace Accord
16:15 - 17:00 Discussion
17:15 Bus departure from the University to Radisson SAS hotel
20:00 Dinner at Rica Ishavshotel

 

23rd October

Subtheme 3:
Norway’s bilateral and multilateral challenges in peacemaking and implementation of accords – Roundtable discussion after introductions
08:30 Taxi departure from Radisson SAS hotel to the University campus
09:00 - 09:45 Introductions by MFA, NORAD and IWGIA
09:45 - 10:30 Roundtable discussion by IWGIA, Galdu, Norad, MFA, Centre for Peace Studies at the University of Tromsø and from the present representatives of national indigenous organizations
10:30 - 11:00 Discussion
11:00 - 11:15 Coffee
Forum update
11:15 - 11:30 Fikre Dessalegn, Dilla University (Ethiopia): Presentation of Dilla University
11:30 - 11:45
Summing up
11:45 - 12:45 Summing up by Robert Hitchcock, professor, University of Michigan
12:45 - 13:00 Closure of the Forum Conference 2009
13:00 - 14:00 Lunch